Rent to rent or guaranteed rent - agent guide

Monday, July 7, 2025

Rent to rent is where an individual or company rents a property from an owner landlord, then lets that property to occupiers and manages it day to day. In return, the owner landlord receives a fixed or guaranteed rent.

This model can work well when it is set up properly. But it also creates extra risk. In many cases, the rent to rent operator is not just acting as an agent. They may also take on legal duties as the occupier’s landlord.

The Renters’ Rights Act changes key parts of the legal framework in England. If you offer rent to rent or guaranteed rent, you should review your agreements, compliance processes and property standards now.

What is rent to rent?

In a standard rent to rent arrangement:

  • the owner landlord grants a lease or commercial agreement to an individual or company
  • that individual or company then lets the property, or rooms within it, to tenants
  • the rent to rent operator collects rent from the occupiers
  • the owner landlord receives an agreed fixed rent

This can look simple on paper. In practice, it creates a chain of legal relationships that must be managed carefully.

How the arrangement should be set up

If you are offering rent to rent or guaranteed rent to a landlord, the agreement with the owner landlord should usually be set up as a commercial lease or similar commercial arrangement.

It should not usually be created as a residential tenancy where you do not live in the property yourself.

Your agreement with the owner landlord should clearly state:

  • who has control of the property
  • whether subletting is allowed
  • who is responsible for repairs
  • who is responsible for licensing and compliance
  • who is responsible for safety requirements
  • how rent is paid
  • how the agreement ends
  • what happens if occupiers remain in place when the commercial agreement ends

If these points are unclear, disputes are far more likely.

Your role in law

In many rent to rent arrangements, the operator becomes the immediate landlord of the tenant or sub-tenant. That matters because the legal duties owed to the occupier may sit with the operator, not the owner landlord.

This can include duties linked to:

  • tenancy agreements
  • repairs
  • property condition
  • deposit protection
  • complaint handling
  • possession and eviction rules

You should not assume that calling the arrangement “guaranteed rent” removes landlord responsibilities.

Tenancy reforms under the Renters’ Rights Act

The Renters’ Rights Act changes the tenancy system for private rented homes in England.

Key changes include:

  • the abolition of fixed-term assured tenancies
  • the move to periodic tenancies as the standard model
  • the end of section 21 no fault evictions
  • a requirement for landlords to rely on valid legal grounds for possession

Under the new system, tenants will generally remain in the property until:

  • they choose to leave and give notice, or
  • the landlord proves a lawful ground for possession

What this means for rent-to-rent arrangements

This matters for rent to rent because your agreement with the owner landlord may have a fixed commercial term, while the occupier’s tenancy will follow the new residential tenancy rules.

Agents and operators should review:

  • whether their tenancy documents still refer to old fixed-term AST wording
  • whether their possession processes rely on rules that no longer apply
  • whether the end of the commercial agreement has been properly considered alongside any ongoing tenant occupation
  • whether responsibilities are clear if the owner landlord wants the property back

The key point is simple. The end of your agreement with the owner landlord does not automatically end the occupier’s rights. If a tenant remains in lawful occupation, possession must still be dealt with properly and lawfully.

Rent and client money

In a typical rent to rent model:

  • the operator collects rent from the occupier
  • the operator pays the agreed amount to the owner landlord
  • the difference is retained by the operator to cover costs and profit

Whether rent received is treated as client money will depend on the legal structure and the wording of the agreement. Agents should make sure their accounting treatment, disclosures and internal controls are accurate.

Legal points to consider

1. Is the property an HMO?

A house in multiple occupation, or HMO, may exist where:

  • three or more people live there
  • those people form more than one household
  • they share facilities such as a kitchen or bathroom

Many rent to rent models involve room lets, so HMO rules are often relevant.

2. Does the property need a licence?

Some properties must be licensed. This may include:

Many rent to rent models involve room lets, so HMO rules are often relevant.

  • mandatory HMO licensing
  • additional HMO licensing set by the local council
  • selective licensing in certain areas

Before the property is marketed or let, check:

  • whether a licence is needed
  • who should hold the licence
  • whether the proposed use is allowed
  • whether licence conditions can be met in practice

3. Does the mortgage allow rent to rent?

The owner landlord should confirm that their mortgage lender allows this kind of arrangement. Consent should be obtained in writing where needed.

4. Does the insurance cover this arrangement?

The owner landlord should also confirm that their insurance policy covers rent to rent or guaranteed rent arrangements, including subletting where relevant.

5. Is the property leasehold?

If the property is leasehold, review the lease carefully. Some leases restrict subletting or require consent from the freeholder or superior landlord.

6. Will a deposit be taken?

If you take a tenancy deposit from an occupier, that deposit must still be protected where the law requires it.

A deposit taken from a tenant should be protected in a government-authorised tenancy deposit protection scheme, such as mydeposits, within the legal deadline. The required prescribed information must also be served correctly.

A deposit paid by the operator to the owner landlord under a commercial agreement is different. That is not usually a tenancy deposit.

Deposit protection remains essential

The Renters’ Rights Act does not remove deposit protection duties.

If you take a deposit from a tenant and fail to protect it properly, the consequences can be serious. These can include:

  • a court order to pay a financial penalty
  • difficulty using possession routes where deposit rules have not been met
  • complaints and disputes
  • enforcement risk and reputational damage

Agents should be clear on:

  • who is taking the deposit
  • who is named as landlord in the tenancy
  • who protects the deposit
  • who serves the prescribed information
  • how deposits are returned or disputed at the end of the tenancy

Clear processes reduce avoidable claims and confusion.

Private Rented Sector Landlord Ombudsman

The Renters’ Rights Act introduces a new Private Rented Sector Landlord Ombudsman in England.

All private landlords with assured or regulated tenancies will be required to join, including landlords involved in rent to rent arrangements where they are the legal landlord of the occupier.

The ombudsman will provide tenants with a route to raise complaints about a landlord’s actions, inaction or behaviour. It will offer a quicker route to resolution than court in many cases, and decisions will be binding.

The ombudsman may require a landlord to:

  • apologise
  • provide information
  • take remedial action
  • pay compensation

Why this matters in rent to rent

In a rent to rent setup, it is vital to identify who the occupier’s landlord is in law. That party may need to join the ombudsman service.

You should review:

  • who contracts with the tenant
  • who handles repairs and complaints
  • whether both agent redress and landlord ombudsman requirements apply
  • how complaints will be managed where both the operator and owner landlord are involved

Penalties for non-compliance

Local councils will have powers to act where landlords fail to join the ombudsman service or continue to operate outside the rules.

Penalties can include:

  • civil penalties of up to £7,000 for an initial breach
  • civil penalties of up to £40,000 for serious, repeated or ongoing breaches
  • criminal prosecution in some cases

Decent Homes Standard

The Renters’ Rights Act applies the Decent Homes Standard to the private rented sector.

This means privately rented properties, including those used in rent to rent arrangements, will need to meet the required standard when the relevant provisions are in force.

While the detail will be supported by regulations, the direction is clear. Properties must be safe, in a reasonable state of repair and suitable for occupation.

For agents and operators, this means there should be clear systems for:

  • inspections
  • repair reporting
  • contractor management
  • record keeping
  • escalation of serious defects
  • oversight of standards across all occupied rooms and shared areas

If a rent to rent property is in poor condition, it is not enough to assume responsibility sits elsewhere. The agreement should make duties clear, but day to day management also needs to match those duties.

Awaab’s Law

Awaab’s Law is being extended to the private rented sector.

This will introduce legal requirements around the investigation and resolution of serious hazards such as damp and mould within set timeframes once the detailed rules are brought into force.

This is a major issue for rent to rent properties, especially where:

  • rooms are let separately
  • there are shared kitchens or bathrooms
  • maintenance responsibility is split between parties
  • reports are passed between operator and owner landlord without action

Agents should have a clear process to:

  • log complaints quickly
  • inspect without delay
  • assess the seriousness of the hazard
  • arrange remedial work
  • keep written records
  • communicate clearly with tenants and landlords

Delays create legal risk. They can also lead to complaints, enforcement action and claims for compensation.

Enforcement and penalties

The Renters’ Rights Act strengthens local authority enforcement powers.

Councils will have broader powers to investigate and act against non-compliance. This includes powers to require information and, in some cases, powers of entry.

For agents operating rent to rent, this means stronger scrutiny of:

  • property conditions
  • licensing
  • deposit protection
  • complaint handling
  • ombudsman membership
  • tenancy paperwork
  • use of possession grounds

Civil penalties

The new framework allows councils to impose:

  • penalties of up to £7,000 for initial or less serious non-compliance
  • penalties of up to £40,000 for serious, repeated or ongoing non-compliance

In some cases, criminal prosecution may also be available.

Rent repayment orders

The Act also strengthens rent repayment orders. These can be an important enforcement tool where certain offences have been committed.

That makes compliance even more important for rent-to-rent operators, particularly where there are complex ownership and management arrangements.

Complaints and redress

Rent to rent complaints can be more complex than standard agency complaints because there may be more than one legal relationship involved.

Depending on the facts, complaints may involve:

  • the agent redress scheme
  • the Private Rented Sector Landlord Ombudsman
  • the local council
  • the courts

This makes good complaint handling essential. Keep records, respond promptly and make sure tenants know where to direct complaints.

Practical steps for agents

If you operate a rent to rent or guaranteed rent model, review your setup now.

Check:

  • your commercial agreement with the owner landlord
  • your tenancy agreements and notices
  • your deposit protection process
  • your complaint handling procedures
  • whether ombudsman membership is required
  • who is responsible for repairs and hazards
  • whether the property meets expected standards
  • whether any licence is needed
  • whether your insurance matches your legal role
  • whether your records are complete and accurate

A clear agreement, strong compliance process and prompt handling of property issues will reduce risk for you, the owner landlord and the tenant.

Final point

Rent to rent can still work, but it needs tighter control than many operators expect. The Renters’ Rights Act raises the standard for complaint handling, property conditions and compliance, and requires a strong approach to day to day management.

If you are offering this model, now is the time to review your documents, confirm your legal role and make sure your processes are fit for the new rules.

Part of the Brown & Brown Team
Copyright © 2024 Property Redress. All rights reserved. Company number: 08994516 Registered office address: 7th Floor Corn Exchange, 55 Mark Lane, London, England, EC3R 7NE Property Redress is approved by Government under the Alternative Dispute Resolution for Consumer Disputes (Competent Authorities and Information) Regulations 2015